Tuesday, May 13, 2025
  • Login
  • PRESS RELEASE
  • ADVERTISE
  • CONTACT
198 Immigration News
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Videos
  • Global News
  • Immigration
  • Blog
  • Sponsorships
  • Books
  • Ads
  • Professional Help
  • Laws updates
  • Work Permit
  • Contact
  • Home
  • Videos
  • Global News
  • Immigration
  • Blog
  • Sponsorships
  • Books
  • Ads
  • Professional Help
  • Laws updates
  • Work Permit
  • Contact
198 Immigration News
No Result
View All Result
Home Immigration News from around the world

Open-Borders Proponents Keep Pushing “Sanctuary Cities” Myth

by The Editor
February 8, 2021
in Immigration News from around the world
0
Open-Borders Proponents Keep Pushing “Sanctuary Cities” Myth
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Email

[ad_1]

Anti-immigration enforcement advocates have lengthy touted the totally debunked delusion that sanctuary cities make America safer as a result of unlawful aliens will turn into extra more likely to report crimes in the event that they face no threat of deportation. This argument is at all times primarily based on both pure opinion, or extraordinarily shaky knowledge. A February 5 “evaluation” written by Harvard PhD candidates in The Washington Put up isn’t any completely different.

First, the authors make no effort
to cover that they already made up their minds on this situation earlier than starting
their analysis. This, after all, hampers their credibility as skilled researchers
who’re supposedly following the scientific methodology (which incorporates approaching
a subject from a standpoint of skepticism to fight cognitive biases). Second,
whereas they declare that their analysis is “empirical,” it’s really nothing
greater than a set of poorly constructed conclusions primarily based on largely
inapplicable correlations.

For instance, the authors tried to assert that immigration enforcement measures hamper crime reporting as a result of, within the cities they examined, “because the depth of [law enforcement measures]elevated, the reported crime fee decreased.” Nevertheless, this assumes that crime nonetheless happens on the similar fee, however that individuals are much less prepared to report it to the authorities. Nevertheless, it’s a well-established indisputable fact that when the regulation is enforced vigorously, fewer folks have a tendency to interrupt the regulation, making crime charges lower. That is for a easy motive – individuals are extra more likely to break the regulation once they know they will get away with it. So this correlation fails to show their speculation in any respect. Quite the opposite, it means that elevated enforcement of our immigration legal guidelines certainly prompted general crime to lower.

The one half-hearted effort made to supply empirical proof that sanctuary cities improve the chance that immigrants will report crimes was the reference of a latest research known as “Immigrant Sanctuary Insurance policies and Crime-Reporting Habits: A Multilevel Evaluation of Reviews of Crime Victimization to Regulation Enforcement, 1980 to 2004.” Nevertheless, this research is fatally flawed for 2 causes:

1. It solely makes use of knowledge from earlier than 2004, when sanctuary cities had been comparatively uncommon. In reality, there have been solely 11 sanctuary jurisdictions in 2000, in comparison with greater than 550 at present. Which means there actually was not sufficient knowledge obtainable to make any form of related comparability to the problem because it exists at present.

2. The report
additionally admits that no research exist which show a causal hyperlink between sanctuary
insurance policies and an elevated willingness to report crimes. As a substitute, the authors
created a set of variables derived from broad correlations in a roundabout way
related to immigration standing and utilized them to hypothetical situations
that did relate to immigration standing. Because the widespread statistical adage goes:
“correlation doesn’t equal causation.” That is very true when the
correlation isn’t instantly associated to the problem being studied.

Lastly, the biased authors additionally bemoaned the truth that “when the chance of deportation goes up, undocumented immigrants and their family are much less more likely to apply for the Supplemental Diet Help Program (SNAP), to depend on Medicaid for well being care, or to hunt assist from the Ladies, Infants and Youngsters Program (WIC).” That is for good motive – it’s illegal for unlawful aliens to obtain federal welfare. Suggesting that sanctuary insurance policies are a very good factor as a result of they encourage welfare fraud isn’t a very sturdy argument for his or her existence.

As is commonly the case with
out-of-touch teachers who promote open borders, this so-called “evaluation”
really gives extra proof that sanctuary cities hurt People than it suggests
that they assist. It hardly takes a set of PhD candidates to grasp
that if a jurisdiction overtly declares that the regulation is not going to be enforced,
lawlessness will improve. Nevertheless, info and knowledge not often get in the best way of
anti-immigration enforcement advocates. Their purpose is to make use of no matter means
obligatory – together with false science – to prop up their People-last agenda.

[ad_2]

Source link

Tags: citiesMythOpenBordersProponentsPushingSanctuary
ShareTweetSend

Related Posts

New Immigration Pathways in Europe
Immigration Blog

New Immigration Pathways in Europe: A Breakdown of Digital Nomad Visas

October 9, 2024
Family Reunification Policies
Immigration Blog

Family Reunification Policies: How Different Countries Approach Visa Delays and Backlogs

October 9, 2024
key changes in 2024 visas
Immigration Blog

Student Visa Changes in 2024: Key Updates in the US, Canada, Australia, and the UK

October 9, 2024
The Impact of Global Inflation on Immigrant Communities
Immigration Blog

The Impact of Global Inflation on Immigrant Communities

October 9, 2024
Climate Refugees
Immigration Blog

Climate Refugees: The Growing Role of Climate Change in Immigration Policy

October 9, 2024
Top Countries with Investor Visa Programs in 2024
Immigration Blog

Top Countries with Investor Visa Programs in 2024: Requirements and Benefits

October 9, 2024
Load More
Next Post
Public Charge Income QUESTIONS: I-944 Declaration of Self Sufficiency (USA Immigration Lawyer)

Public Charge Income QUESTIONS: I-944 Declaration of Self Sufficiency (USA Immigration Lawyer)

Hilton prepares to take a deep dive into the US immigration system

Hilton prepares to take a deep dive into the US immigration system

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Biden Administration Ends ‘Safe Third Country’ Agreements

Biden Administration Ends ‘Safe Third Country’ Agreements

February 9, 2021
Govt of Canada sets – The College of Immigration and Citizenship Consultants | IRCC News 2021

Govt of Canada sets – The College of Immigration and Citizenship Consultants | IRCC News 2021

August 12, 2021
Family Members Separated at Border May Each Get Up to $450,000 : immigration

Family Members Separated at Border May Each Get Up to $450,000 : immigration

November 1, 2021
US CITIZENS ALLOWED ENTRY IN PHILIPPINES | UPDATED OCTOBER 25

US CITIZENS ALLOWED ENTRY IN PHILIPPINES | UPDATED OCTOBER 25

October 27, 2021
[5] Elysian EMPIRE?! | EU4 Third Odyssey | Elysia

[5] Elysian EMPIRE?! | EU4 Third Odyssey | Elysia

October 20, 2021
The Largest Immigrant Groups in Switzerland (By country of birth from 1960 to 2020)

The Largest Immigrant Groups in Switzerland (By country of birth from 1960 to 2020)

September 14, 2021
Dubai UAE New Immigration Update 2020 | UAE Dubai Visas Closed For Pakistanis and  Indians

Dubai UAE New Immigration Update 2020 | UAE Dubai Visas Closed For Pakistanis and Indians

August 22, 2021
US Plans to Open Borders for Foreign Travelers | US Travel Ban Updates | Border Opening Aug. 2021

US Plans to Open Borders for Foreign Travelers | US Travel Ban Updates | Border Opening Aug. 2021

August 18, 2021
Brexit

How Brexit Continues to Affect UK Immigration: Challenges for EU Nationals

0
japan boosting immigration

Immigration Trends in Asia: The Rise of Skilled Worker Programs in Japan and South Korea

0
US future immigration

Immigration Policy Shifts in the US: What to Expect with the Upcoming Elections

0
Top Countries with Investor Visa Programs in 2024

Top Countries with Investor Visa Programs in 2024: Requirements and Benefits

0
Climate Refugees

Climate Refugees: The Growing Role of Climate Change in Immigration Policy

0
key changes in 2024 visas

Student Visa Changes in 2024: Key Updates in the US, Canada, Australia, and the UK

0
Family Reunification Policies

Family Reunification Policies: How Different Countries Approach Visa Delays and Backlogs

0
New Immigration Pathways in Europe

New Immigration Pathways in Europe: A Breakdown of Digital Nomad Visas

0
New Immigration Pathways in Europe

New Immigration Pathways in Europe: A Breakdown of Digital Nomad Visas

October 9, 2024
Family Reunification Policies

Family Reunification Policies: How Different Countries Approach Visa Delays and Backlogs

October 9, 2024
key changes in 2024 visas

Student Visa Changes in 2024: Key Updates in the US, Canada, Australia, and the UK

October 9, 2024
The Impact of Global Inflation on Immigrant Communities

The Impact of Global Inflation on Immigrant Communities

October 9, 2024
Climate Refugees

Climate Refugees: The Growing Role of Climate Change in Immigration Policy

October 9, 2024
Top Countries with Investor Visa Programs in 2024

Top Countries with Investor Visa Programs in 2024: Requirements and Benefits

October 9, 2024
US future immigration

Immigration Policy Shifts in the US: What to Expect with the Upcoming Elections

October 9, 2024
Brexit

How Brexit Continues to Affect UK Immigration: Challenges for EU Nationals

October 9, 2024

CATEGORIES

  • Australia Immigration
  • Canada Immigration
  • EU Immigration
  • Immigrants Work Permit
  • Immigration Advocacy Groups
  • Immigration Blog
  • Immigration Laws update
  • Immigration News from around the world
  • Immigration Sponsorship
  • Professional Help
  • Uncategorized
  • USA Immigration
  • Video Profile from around the world
  • Home
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • DMCA
  • Cookie Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Contact

Copyright © 2021 198 Immigration News .

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Videos
  • Global News
  • Immigration
  • Blog
  • Sponsorships
  • Books
  • Ads
  • Professional Help
  • Laws updates
  • Work Permit
  • Contact

Copyright © 2021 198 Immigration News .